How to choose the best firepit (2024)

Fire pits are the latest on trend piece of outdoor furniture. They provide a cosy warmth on cool evenings, but can also act as focal points during social gatherings. If you're considering investing in a fire pit, you may be overwhelmed by all of the choices on the market today. Our range of fire pits come in a wide range of shapes, sizes and different materials, so how do you choose the best firepit for your garden?

Cast iron vs steel

When choosing your fire pit, the material from which it is constructed is an important factor for many – which is best, cast iron or steel?

Both of these materials have their advantages and disadvantages which we will explore to choose the best fire pit for you.

Cast iron fire pits

Cast iron is sometimes seen as the superior choice for fire pits due to its heat retaining properties and durability, allowing you to create a lot more heat by burning either wood or coal. As cast iron is a thicker and denser metal, it takes longer to heat up than steel but holds the heat for longer. Cast iron has a carbon content greater than steel and is able to withstand harsh weather with minimal maintenance.

An important factor in choosing between a cast iron or stainless-steel fire pit is its position outdoors. Cast iron is substantially heavier than steel so once in place, it can be harder to move resulting in a permanent location in your garden.

How to choose the best firepit (1)

Also, cast iron tends to take on a more industrial look and during the moulding process, it is easy to cast patterns and designs making them more ornate, as well as aging better. Cast iron wood burners were popular in yesteryear and bring a sense of classic heritage with them.

Our popular Hoole Cast Iron Fire Pit with its stylish, matt black colour will blend into any scheme, whilst being built to last and will age and rust beautifully over time.

Steel fire pits

Steel fire pits are just as good as cast iron fire pits and have the advantage of heating up quicker and emitting the same level of warmth. However, due to steel being thinner than iron, steel fire pits can lose heat quicker after the fire dies down.

A benefit of steel fire pits is that they are more lightweight and therefore more portable around your garden. They also more contemporary look to them, smoother lines and sleek silhouettes can be welded easily making them perfect for modern gardens.

How to choose the best firepit (2)

Our on trend designs include the stylish and timeless Hoole Cesta Steel Fire Basket, as well as the show stopping Wakehurst Outdoor Fireplace With Wood Storage which instantly elevates the look of your garden patio.

Steel also has a long lifespan, needs minimal maintenance and designed to stay outdoors throughout the year. The more you use your steel fire pit, the more beautiful it becomes as it will naturally age and develop a mature patina effect.

How to choose the best firepit (3)

From reading our guide, you can see that when choosing between a cast iron or steel fire pit, there is no one option better than the other. Whilst there is a slight difference in design and heat retention, there is no reason to rule out either material and both will act as a delightful centrepiece in your garden.

Our stunning collection includes cast iron and steel fire pit bowls, fire baskets, and fireplaces. Choose the best firepit for you from the Gardenesque range.

How to choose the best firepit (2024)


How to choose the best firepit? ›

The fire pit you choose should strike a balance between quality and cost. Better quality will cost more, so size, style, fuel, and materials will influence the price tag. However, if you plan to use your fire pit often and for years to come, a solid design with durable materials will eventually pay for itself.

How to pick the best fire pit? ›

Things to Consider When Buying Fire Pits

In addition to deciding between a gas vs. wood fire pit, be sure to select one that fits within your space and also matches your style. You don't need a lot of extra room to set up a fire pit and create ambience and fun in your backyard.

What shape fire pit is best? ›

Round Fire Pit:

It also has the advantage of its shape to allow a more open feel and for people to move around naturally. If you have a natural landscape in your backyard, a round fire pit will be a well-suited choice. The round shape encourages more conversation in the open space.

What is the perfect firepit? ›

Overall, the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 is hard to beat regarding function and value, making it a fantastic pick for those who want an all-around, well-designed fire pit. The dual burn of the Solo Stove (down and right) not only reduces smoke, it creates a lot more flame than the other two traditional fire pits.

Should I get a deep or shallow fire pit? ›

A good depth for an in-ground fire pit is between 6 to 12 inches. This range ensures adequate ventilation for the fire while keeping it contained. Remember, too shallow can make your fire pit less safe as embers can easily escape, while too deep can hinder oxygen supply, making your fire smoky.

What is a good size fire pit for backyard? ›

Small fire pit dimensions should measure 3 feet wide, while a large pit can go up to 6 feet wide. Ideally a fire pit should be between 36 and 44 inches wide (including the width of the walls) in order to comfortably seat multiple people around it whilst still maintaining an intimate setting.

Is iron or steel better for a fire pit? ›

Cast iron is sometimes seen as the superior choice for fire pits due to its heat retaining properties and durability, allowing you to create a lot more heat by burning either wood or coal. As cast iron is a thicker and denser metal, it takes longer to heat up than steel but holds the heat for longer.

What is the safest type of fire pit? ›

Propane fire pits are generally considered one of the safest options. Let's take a look at some of the features that make them a good choice.

What is the longest lasting material for a fire pit? ›

Natural stone is most commonly used for permanent fire pit installations. This material features a naturally textured finish and is also highly durable throughout almost any weather conditions. You'll typically find both wood-burning and gas stone fire pits.

What is the best Btu for a fire pit? ›

Takeaway:A good BTU for a fire pit is between 40,000 and 50,000 BTU for a small to medium space and up to 200,000 BTU for a large outdoor space.

What should I put in the bottom of my fire pit? ›

Best materials to put in the bottom of a fire pit
  1. Here's what to use in your fire pit. Both permanent and portable fire pits can burn brighter with the right lining materials. ...
  2. Sand. A thin layer of sand can help to contain any fire. ...
  3. Gravel. ...
  4. Crushed rock. ...
  5. Glass. ...
  6. Bricks. ...
  7. Concrete. ...
  8. Rocks.
Feb 22, 2021

Should I put anything in the bottom of my fire pit? ›

Placing a layer of sand or gravel at the bottom of a fire pit can help with heat distribution and protect the base from extreme temperatures. It also makes cleaning up ash easier.

Is round or square fire pit better? ›

Both shapes of fire pits offer different levels of practicality. Round fire pits have the advantage of a more uniform distribution of heat into the surroundings. Moreover, the round shape tends to feel more open and allows people to move about it more naturally while encouraging conversations.

Is glass or rock better for fire pit? ›

Generally speaking, both media options are durable. However, over time, the rocks will break down and deteriorate. Depending on how often your fireplace is enjoyed, the lava rocks will need to be replaced every 1-2 years. Alternatively, fire glass will last for a much longer time than lave rock.

What type of fire pit gives off the most heat? ›

A wood-burning fire pit gives off the most heat. Adequately seasoned wood is easy to burn and produces a large, bright fire that gives off a lot of heat, even in a small fire pit designed to save precious outdoor space.

Which is better in ground or above ground fire pit? ›

While portable above-ground fire pits are cheaper and easier to install, permanent in-ground fire pits are better for most homes. They last longer with less care needed. They look nicer, built into the yard.


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 6383

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.